Culture & Society
Gates' arrest is the essence of American racism
By: Devona Walker
(Add to your loop)
Tue, 07/21/2009 - 09:20
0
Votes

Last Thursday, the Cambridge Police Department outside Boston took racial profiling to an all-time low. They arrested 58-year-old Henry Louis Gates Jr., the publisher of TheRoot.com, Harvard professor and director of the W.E.B. Dubois Institute for African and African American Research, outside his home.
Apparently, a white woman passed by, saw two black men with backpacks outside a nice home, assumed they were burglars, even though one of the men in question is almost 60 years old and immediately called the police. She was still there, with cell phone in hand, when the Cambridge police arrived on the scene.
Now, where should we begin?
The incident occured in the middle of the day, and when the police showed up, they realized Gates was the owner of the home. He was, in fact, not arrested on suspicion of burglary, but for disturbing the peace and acting belligerent after the officers demanded he come back outside to show identification.
Both sides remember the details differently. While the officer says Gates at first refused to produce identification, Gates said he immediately showed the officer two forms of identification. On Tuesday, due no doubt to all the racism outrage, the Cambridge police dropped charges against Gates, which leads to questions about who was in the wrong.
After Gates produced ID, the Cambridge police called the Harvard police, who then called a Harvard maintenance worker to vouch for Gates' identity. And then, of course, there was that white woman passerby still lingering around, clutching her cell phone.
According to the police report, the police were angered after Gates called them racists in front of the growing crowd of people nearby. Gates, in their opinion, committed the cardinal sin. He called them out on the spot for racial profiling and still the officer remains confused, puzzled and bewildered that Gates was upset.
This goes to the very basis of racism in America. Some people just don’t get it. They don’t connect our rage with their ignorance. All they see is the rage. In 1994, Gates wrote Colored People: A Memoir, and one of the passages I find particularly interesting:
Completely by the accident of racism, we have been bound together with people with whom we may or may not have something in common, just because we are "black." Thirty million Americans are black, and 30 million is a lot of people.
One day you wonder: What do the misdeeds of a Mike Tyson have to do with me? So why do I feel implicated? And how can I not feel racial decrimination when I can feel racial pride? ...I want to be black, to know black, to luxuriate in whatever I might be calling blackness at any particular time -- but to do so in order to come out the other side, to experience a humanity that is neither colorless nor reducible to color.
See, you have to understand: The local authorities didn’t recognize Gates, because he doesn't rap and isn't a member of the NBA or NFL. When he warned them that they'd be sorry for harassing him, they accused him of disturbing the peace — in front of his own home after several unnecessary phone calls to check his story. If that's not the essence of racial profiling at its best, I don't know what would be. All I know is they definitely messed with the wrong brother.
Devona Walker is theloop21.com's senior financial and political reporter. She is a veteran journalist who has worked for the New York Times and the Associated Press and can be reached at devona@theloop21.com.
Most Active Discussion on this Topic
New Year's resolution
by - Tue, 12/15/2009 - 11:39RELATED STORIES
-
T.I.'s clothing line 'Akoo' proves fashion isn't for the prudish at heartThu, 03/11/2010 - 01:00Is it as bad as they say? ...
-
A dire warning about America’s impending demiseSun, 03/07/2010 - 01:00Pulitzer Prize-winner Chris Hedges gives warning of the demise of Western Civilization. ...
-
Maybe, just maybe, it's the dating model that has us screwedFri, 03/05/2010 - 13:12Maybe the way we date is the reason we're all single. ...
-
Desiree Rogers is too much, too little and too lateFri, 03/05/2010 - 13:10The last week of Black History Month. ...



COMMENTS
I'm an African American man, and when I hear these type of stories, it often takes a lot of my energy. The media will take a story such as this and run with it. There are so very many racial injustices that occur every day, that are not reported. This is a joke to me. Is this story newsworthy or interesting because he is a Harvard professor? How about talking about some beatings, perhaps, or some wrongful incarcerations, or hiring discrimination.
I have had bad experiences with racist police officers, and have had situations in which they changed their perception and treatment of me, after a conversation. I'm willing to bet that both parties gave a biased version of what happened. First off, I am always under the assumption that many police officers are "power freaks", and stereotpe people. However, I can remember "not wanting" to answer questions and because I felt that they were targeting me. I'm not convinced that this professor immediately showed his I.D. The officer probably didn't treat the professor with the correct amount of dignity, most likely. We all know that many police officers have big egos, and don't enjoy being "fronted off."
What bothers me, is that stories like this are overblown, and stories of severe injustices and inprisonment are not told at all. When the media jumps all over these stories, then Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton are all over it. Eventually, there is the perception that we are always mad, and whining about the white man. I just need to see more balance. Too much of one story, and not enough of others that illustrate severe injustices that ruin people's lives, or injustices that deserve more publicity than this successful Harvard who followed some power-hungry (and maybe very well racist) police officer outside and called him a racist in front of people.
The aftermath of the arrest of Henry Louis Gates, Jr. saw some very negative fallout and accusations of racism, and there were repeated requests to hear the Gates 911 Call. The Gates 9/11 call has been released, and there isn't mention of the race in the call. The issue flared out even more after President Obama made a remarked towards the incident. Gates was trying to get into his own home after returning from a trip, and the door was jammed. In the process of trying to gain access, police were called thinking it was a burglary. Gates apparently became hostile to officers, and was booked for that reason, charges having later been dropped. No suits have been filed, but no one needs payday loans to get the Gates 911 Call transcripts. Personally, the incident is more on misunderstanding in both party. The police went into the house for a possible burglary and on the other hand, Mr. Gates was surprised to see an officer in his house. I just hope that this incident won’t lead to a more complicated racial issue.
Post new comment