Politics
An open letter to NAACP President Ben Jealous
In order for the organization to survive, it will be necessary to attract younger members... you are failing miserably.
By: Mychal Smith | TheLoop21
(Add to your loop)
Sun, 07/25/2010 - 11:35
0
Votes

Dear Mr. Ben Jealous,
Last week, I wrote an article in which I suggested, albeit amid some criticism, that while the NAACP may be struggling to remain relevant, the 101 year-old organization has been taking some important steps toward a renewed sense of purpose and return to past prestige. I praised the decision to appoint you President and CEO and the role you have played in broadening the scope of issues which the NAACP has found pertinent. In the week since my article was published, your organization has continued to make headlines for...various reasons. The most recent attention grabber has been your role in the ouster of Shirley Sherrod from her position at the USDA over her wrongly perceived comments regarding racial bias.
As a 23 year-old black male living in America, I suppose I am part of the key demographic that you and the NAACP wish to bring into the fold and breed as the next generation of civil rights activists. In order for the organization to survive, it will be necessary to attract younger members. I’d like to tell you this now: you are failing miserably.
You have to understand, even to those of us who are students of history and are familiar with the role the NAACP has played in dismantling the system of racism that is part of the foundation of this country, you’re still sort of a joke. I’m a part of generation that grew up using the NAACP as a punchline. There have been many instances where I and my peers, at the slightest hint of anything racial, have exclaimed “I’m calling the NAACP!” in jest. The humor derived from the idea that the NAACP never actually did anything and our minor skirmish was just the type of inane melodrama the NAACP could handle. We were kidding; you all have taken the “truth in humor” anecdote to new levels.
Read More:
- In defense of Andrew Breitbart
- NAACP needs an overhaul to keep from embarrassing itself
- The Tea Party fires up their base by fanning the flames of racism
- Shirley Sherrod and “liberal journalist” hoax, Fox News' latest boogeyman
The Hallmark greeting card incident earlier this year was embarrassing enough, but this situation with Miss Sherrod is appalling. Of course, you weren’t the only character in this saga, but the incompetence you displayed is wholly uninspiring. The fact that a faux-journalist was able to bait you into reprimanding a public official for racism based on a context-less soundbite from a video which you yourselves own and could have viewed at any time and subsequently dismissed the claim of racism before this story gained traction, makes you look... I hate to use the word “stupid”, but it’s not too far off. You’re not stupid, I would never say you are, but this act was stupid.
RELATED STORIES
-
Criminalizing weed is so bad even the cops are against itFri, 09/03/2010 - 00:00Battle lines are drawn as we near the November vote on Prop 19, blacks are hurt more by criminalization of marijuana ...
-
Contaminated eggs: Playing Russian roulette with our foodThu, 09/02/2010 - 00:00It seems our grocery store meat is crawling with potentially harmful bacteria. ...
-
Thanks to Eddie Bernice Johnson, I give up on the CBCWed, 09/01/2010 - 12:09The CBC Foundation does more to help politicians than disavantaged kids ...
-
Thousands dead in Iraq, a trillion spent, it's time to move onWed, 09/01/2010 - 09:00The president made the best of a situation he inherited, one that has no good ending ...
theloop Twitter
- I am not in favor of charter schools as I feel yet another layer is added to the educational system ... On Charter vs. Public Schools: Fear and loathing in education
- While I don't disagree with the broad points of the article (don't try to keep up with the Joneses, ... On A "Lottery Ticket" is no ticket to wealth
- Kim Kardashian allegedly decided at a young age that she wanted to be the star of a reality televi... On Why Kim Kardashian is bad for Armenian women
- Interesting thought. Definitely something to consider. I think a lot of people like to stay close ... On It's time for a new Great Migration, out of the hood

COMMENTS
Post new comment
I am not affiliated with the NAACP. What follows are my opinions alone.
Jealous is aware of the prevalence of your demographic's sentiment. So is the NAACP Board of Directors.
An expensive marketing campaign using a few celebrities your generation emulates or reveres would likely bring tens of thousands of you into the fold. There's little good marketing campaigns can't do these days. Whoever wants to get more consumers to buy, followers to follow, or potential grassroots volunteers to do the things actual grassroots volunteers do merely needs to build a brand that will do the desired psychological trick, a brand that will "move the crowd" as it were. Ask Tom Burrell. But the NAACP can't afford to spend $50 million to persuade a much larger proportion of your generation to join its ranks. It can't afford to do what it would need to do, marketing-wise, to persuade tens of thousands more of you it's the new old-school cool, or that it's the latest must-follow Twitter account, or that you should sign-up to put in the type of good work you could put in via the local NAACP chapter whether you agree with NAACP's national leadership or not, whether you like its brand or not.
If anyone is able and willing to chop wood and carry water, when the cameras are turned off, when the computers are turned off, when the smart phones are turned off, then there is a NAACP program at a local chapter that will enable him or her to put his or her hours in. The NAACP has the infrastructure necessary to put your generation to work for the communities that desperately need you. A key question we ask when my fraternity brothers and I get together for dinner is does your generation really want to chop wood and carry water?
What would motivate your generation to perform the arduous labors of effective and altruistic activism is very different from what compelled your grandparents and great-grandparents to do it. No one is sure what, if anything, could motivate most of you to tear yourselves away from the internet long enough to roll-up your sleeves long enough to put in some work through any organization. What we do know is that organizations like the NAACP must compete for your generation's interest and time against technologies and trends that did not exist four generations ago. Moreover, thanks to the legal and legislative successes of the previous four generations, a much smaller proportion of your generation is willing to be activists of any sort, especially the sort that chops wood and carries water sans Blackberries and iPhones. So, on one hand, the world has changed in ways that have made your generation more interested in digital activities unrelated to real world activism. On the other hand, the NAACP did such a good job during the last century that there are signs it is working itself out of a job. That the consensus view of the late 30-somethings, 40-somethings, and early 50-something fraternity brothers I have dinner with.
In spite of this, the NAACP will likely continue to maintain a strong enough base to stay relevant and important this century. If it senses too many from its base are leaving, it will choose a new leader. There will be a renewed buzz around the nation about the new leader. There will be blogosphere, Facebook, and Twitter debates about whether the NAACP selected the right leader, whether he will be able to bring younger people into the NAACP (as Jealous was and is expected to do), whether she was the right choice as the NAACP's first African American woman to be selected CEO, and whether the NAACP is still relevant or effective. These dbates will keep us talking about the NAACP. When we talk about it, we will talk about its magnanimous history. Members of the intelligentsia, looking to help us put our dinner conversations, blog conversations, Facebook wall posts, and Twitter exchanges in proper context, will write a few pieces to remind us all of what the NAACP has done. We will recall the ways it transformed our nation. Some of us will agree that two of the biggest reasons why the younger folks aren't as interested in being activists as previous generations are (1) because they are more interested in other, funner things and (2) because the NAACP put in the work last century that made it easy for them to convince themselves they don't need to be half the activists their grandfathers, great-grandfathers, grandmothers, and great-grandmothers were.
Your friend,
@DegreedUp
I am a fan of you sir, DegreedUp.
Excellent letter!!! I couldn't agree more. Well done sir!
Well written.n He needs to reflect, stay away from the lights, and return with a refreshing perspective.
He did his job efficiently outing the T Party, although he had his guard down at the end, with the Shirley incident.
It all worked out for the better. Paradoxically, the incident around Shirley opened up more of what Ben was on about, and gave us all a chance to recognize what's important, politics or helping people. She was the hope for all of us, that we could overcome.
The real losers were the ones who initiated and manipulated this entire debacle. They, Breitbart and Faux News will have class action suits for decades. Sounds like Ms Shirley already has one pending.
President Ben Jealous, thank you for your efforts and the next time around you'll be more aware and prepared.
The NAACP has long ceased to be relevant to anything. They keep trying not to step on WHITE FOLKS toes and remain the "go to' folks when the racists in America get too obvious with their Bullsh*t. The Shirley Sherrod screw up exposed them ,so let us hope they will now just go away...
I agree the NAACP has long ceased to be relevant, but I find your language to be divisive. We must understand that racists, black and white, are everywhere; and that ignorance begets ignorance. Someone, somewhere has to rise above, and overcome; and that isn't just limited to pissing off "WHITE FOLKS."
It means shrug them off, racists on both sides, and live your life yourself. Hold yourself accountable, it starts with you, not "us" or "them."
It just feels like you think all white folks are bad guys, and that's simply not the case. I have a few white friends, I've stayed away from the ones suffering from white guilt, and I've had a pretty good time just not giving a sh*t.